Home > Trulia Voices Home > Ohio > Medina County > Medina > 44256 > Home Buying > Question

Can an exterior appraisal value go down significantly after a walk-thru appraisal?

Mshaw97
Home Buyer
Ohio

Quick question, for which I am pretty sure there is a variable of answers. We are purchasing a foreclosure home and are asking the bank for 180k. They did an exterior only appraisal which came back with a value of 237k.

Now, we have several issues with this, especially considering the comps used were for homes nearly half the size, but we will ignore that for now. The bank has now ordered a full walk-through appraisal due to their new "awareness" that this is a vacant home.

So, since the original appraisal value was lower than it most likely should be, we are worried the value will go down to below the 180k benchmark to still qualify for the loan since the home is in somewhat disrepair due to being a foreclosure (we have 20% down).

Can the value of an appraisal go DOWN after an initial exterior appraisal, or only stay the same/ go up? Is there anything we need to worry about?

Answers (4)
Thomas Seeley
Agent
Akron, OH

If the property appraises for less then your original offer then the best thing to do is write up an addendum stating just that to the seller through your agent and renegotiate the price assuming that the lender will still give you the loan first of course and they will let you know.If it goes down then that should save you money anyways and if they won't give you the loan then it wasn't meant to be.

Mon Jun 15 2009, 22:15
Carla Boyert
Agent
Medina County, OH

I agree with both answers on many levels. My question to you is who is your REALTOR? If you are wanting to purchase a bank owned home you need an agent that can work through these types of homes. That REALTOR should have some type of foreclosed bank owned property experience. Becareful, remember there are little or no disclosures with these listings.

Tue Jan 27 2009, 10:56
Scott Godzyk
Agent
New Hampshire

An exterior driveby value is usually always higher than an interior appraisal. the exterior doesnt show interior condition, age of the furnace, electric, plumbing and such. condition plays a huge part of value. from the outside it may look tidyt but from the inside you can see the homes true value. so yes they often go down when someone gets inside to do a real appraisal.

Sat Oct 18 2008, 08:55
John Wirsing
Agent
Cleveland, OH
FIRST ANSWER

Absolutely!
The appraisals can vary. An exterior appraisal by definition only judes the exterior of THAT home in THAT neighborhood. The price opinion must asume that the property is in average condition.
If the value drops below $180K, then the mortgage may not go through.
By the same token, you may not want the house at $180,000 if the appraisers opinion of that property is less than your purchase price.
Would you really want to BUY at an above market price?
If it fails to appraise, you may wish to suggest to the seller that since you cannot obtain financing at $180,000, that you need to be released from the deal with return of your earnest money or you need to renegotiate the purchase price to be in line with the appraisal.

Sat Oct 18 2008, 08:13

Didn’t find what you were looking for? Ask a question!

More Q&A about Home Buying in 44256

View all »
What is drive by exterior appraisal?
Answered Sat Oct 31 2009, 12:42 by Sandi Walker in 44256
Read all 4 answers
can a non us citizen buy a home?
Answered Tue Dec 23 2008, 22:41 by Voices Member in 44256
Read all 5 answers
how to calculate abid on new construction?
Answered Wed Jun 11 2008, 07:45 by James Gordon PBD S… in 44256
Read all 4 answers
Why are homes in Medina, OH so expensive?
Answered Sun Mar 9 2008, 19:54 by Art Hotes in 44256
Read all 4 answers
Search Advice & Opinions

Ask a question

Got a real estate question? Get answers from locals, experts and real estate pros.
Ask
Email me when…

Learn more

View all » 1 - 3 of 37
Copyright © 2009 Trulia, Inc. All rights reserved.   |   Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
Help us improve our service—send us feedback